Rethinking Fitness Norms: Hegseth’s Vision for Combat-Ready Soldiers

Saluting soldier in uniform with American flags background.

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has mandated universal physical fitness standards for all military combat personnel, eliminating gender-specific requirements in a move that will reshape the armed forces.

Quick Takes

  • Hegseth signed a memorandum requiring the same physical fitness standards for men and women in all combat roles.
  • Military services have 60 days to propose changes to their fitness standards based solely on operational demands.
  • The policy aims to ensure military readiness and prevent the lowering of standards to accommodate different groups.
  • Current combat positions already have stringent gender-neutral standards, but this policy formalizes and extends the approach.
  • The changes must be implemented by the end of October 2025.

Uniform Standards for Combat Readiness

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has issued a directive mandating gender-neutral physical fitness standards for all combat positions across the U.S. military. The order requires military services to identify combat arms jobs, including special operations and infantry, which demand heightened physical fitness levels. According to the memo, physical requirements for these positions will be based solely on operational demands and combat readiness, not adjusted for gender or age. This significant policy shift builds upon Hegseth’s previous March 12 memorandum addressing military standards for physical fitness, body composition, and grooming regulations.

Military leaders now have 60 days to propose changes to their fitness standards and 30 days to provide an interim report on their progress. The Pentagon’s directive effectively eliminates lower physical fitness standards for women in combat units, a change that could potentially reduce the number of women who qualify for these roles. While gender-specific standards will remain for some non-combat military positions, the new requirements ensure that anyone serving in combat must meet identical physical benchmarks regardless of gender.

Combat Readiness Over Identity Politics

The Defense Secretary announced the new policy via video on social media platform X after returning from a trip to Japan. In the announcement, Hegseth emphasized that combat effectiveness must take priority over identity considerations. The directive specifically addresses concerns that standards might be lowered to accommodate certain demographics, potentially compromising military readiness. “As the nature of warfare evolves and the demands on our service members grow more complex, it is imperative that we assess and refine the physical fitness standards that enable our readiness and lethality,” said Hegseth. Currently, the military operates with a two-part system for fitness standards: routine annual tests that vary by age and gender, and more rigorous standards for specific combat roles.

Many combat positions already maintain stringent fitness standards that apply equally to all service members regardless of demographic factors. The Army and Marine Corps have specific physical requirements for combat roles that are not adjusted based on gender or age. Special operations forces, which already have some of the military’s most demanding fitness requirements, will continue to maintain their elevated standards under the new directive. The memo emphasizes that these elite units require peak physical conditioning for mission success.

Historical Context and Implementation Challenges

The U.S. military has long debated how to fairly assess women’s physical fitness for combat jobs and leadership roles. In 2022, the Army adjusted its grading standards for women and older service members after a RAND study revealed higher failure rates among these groups. Different branches of the military have historically maintained varying fitness test standards for men and women, a practice that will now end for combat-designated positions. The implementation of this policy will require complex assessments to determine which specific roles qualify as combat arms.

Hegseth has previously expressed concerns about fitness standards and women in combat roles, stating directly that women should not be allowed in combat units if they cannot meet the same fitness standards as men. This new directive reflects those views, prioritizing combat effectiveness over demographic representation goals. The ultimate success of the initiative will depend on the military’s commitment to maintaining appropriately high standards for all service members, ensuring that readiness and operational capability remain the primary focus of America’s armed forces.

Sources:

Hegseth orders fitness standards to be gender neutral for combat jobs. Many already are

Pentagon Eliminates Lower Fitness Standards for Women in Combat Roles

Pete Hegseth Requires Everyone in Combat Units to Meet the Same Physical Fitness Standards

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR