Judge’s Fate Sealed After Shocking Incident with Spouse Ends Tragically

Judges hand holding a gavel near documents

California Superior Court Judge Jeffrey Ferguson faces 40 years to life in prison after being convicted of second-degree murder for fatally shooting his wife Sheryl during an alcohol-fueled argument in their Anaheim Hills home.

Quick Takes

  • Judge Jeffrey Ferguson was found guilty of second-degree murder for shooting his wife with a .40-caliber Glock handgun during a domestic dispute.
  • The conviction came after a retrial, as an earlier jury deadlocked 11-1 in favor of a guilty verdict.
  • Ferguson claimed the shooting was accidental, but prosecutors successfully argued it was murder given his extensive firearms training.
  • Authorities discovered 47 weapons and over 26,000 rounds of ammunition at Ferguson’s home during the investigation.
  • Evidence revealed Ferguson consumed alcohol during court lunch breaks before returning to hear cases, prompting a review of his past judicial decisions.

From Respected Judge to Convicted Murderer

Orange County Superior Court Judge Jeffrey Ferguson’s fall from grace culminated in his conviction for second-degree murder on Thursday. The 72-year-old jurist, who had served on the bench since 2015 after a long career as a prosecutor, now finds himself facing decades behind bars for fatally shooting his wife Sheryl in their Anaheim Hills home. The shooting followed what prosecutors described as a heated argument over family finances that began earlier that day at a restaurant where the couple had been dining with their adult son. Ferguson had been drinking alcohol before returning home, where the dispute escalated to its tragic conclusion.

Ferguson’s defense team maintained throughout both trials that the shooting was accidental, claiming the gun discharged while the judge was removing it from an ankle holster. However, prosecutors successfully argued that Ferguson’s extensive firearms training and experience made such an accident implausible. The jury ultimately rejected the defense’s version of events, concluding that Ferguson intentionally shot his wife in the chest during their argument, though without the premeditation that would have constituted first-degree murder.

Evidence and Aftermath of the Fatal Shooting

The case against Ferguson was strengthened by text messages he sent immediately after the shooting. In a message to his court clerk and bailiff, Ferguson admitted to the shooting and expressed remorse, writing, “I just lost it. I just shot my wife.” This damning evidence, coupled with testimony from Ferguson’s son who disarmed his father and attempted to perform CPR on his dying mother, painted a clear picture for jurors of the judge’s culpability. The search of Ferguson’s residence following the shooting revealed an arsenal of 47 weapons and more than 26,000 rounds of ammunition, underscoring his familiarity with firearms.

Prior to the conviction, Ferguson had been free on $2 million bail but was barred from presiding over cases due to the felony charge against him. The verdict was reached after a day of deliberations in what was actually Ferguson’s second trial. The first trial ended in a mistrial when the jury deadlocked 11-1 in favor of conviction. The retrial was presided over by Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Eleanor J. Hunter to avoid potential conflicts of interest within the Orange County judicial system, where Ferguson had worked for years.

Broader Implications for the Judicial System

Perhaps most disturbing among the revelations at trial was evidence that Ferguson regularly consumed alcohol during lunch breaks before returning to the bench to hear cases. This shocking breach of judicial ethics has prompted a comprehensive review of Ferguson’s past cases, raising questions about the integrity of his rulings and potential grounds for appeals. Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer, who acknowledged having known the Fergusons for decades, described the case as emotionally challenging but emphasized the importance of holding Ferguson accountable.

Ferguson’s attorney, Cameron Talley, indicated plans to appeal the verdict while expressing respect for the jury’s decision. “I respect the jury’s verdict,” Talley said. “At the same time, we all know that juries don’t always get it right… I still believe in Jeff.” The conviction includes not only second-degree murder but also a felony gun enhancement, which together could result in a sentence of 40 years to life in prison. Ferguson’s sentencing is scheduled for June 13, marking the final chapter in this shocking fall from judicial authority to criminal conviction.

Sources:

Jury convicts California judge of second-degree murder in wife’s death, prosecutor’s office says

Jury convicts a California judge of second-degree murder in his wife’s shooting death

Southern California judge found guilty of fatally shooting wife

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR